Both the first and the second spots in the Indian Administrative services examination went to women this year; an encouraging performance by them. Out of the successful candidates, the male-female ratio was not so good, about 6 to 1, but it would be interesting to know the ratio at application level. I have a feeling far fewer women apply at all for the IAS, only the rather more serious and qualified ones; and the ratio of successful to non-successful women applicants may be therefore higher than the male. In any case, girls are getting in on their own merit, and it is encouraging to see. As far as I know, there have been no reservations for women in the services.
Meanwhile, an interesting twist to the difficult merit - reservation issue. The prinicipal of St. Stephen's College suggested the college reserve 40% of its seats -
for men!!
As is the case in many medical colleges, as well, girls apparently outnumber boys almost 60 to 40 in most disciplines in the college, an erstwhile men's college. So is there a place for reserving seats for men? A related question - should girls' colleges open themselves up to allowing men to enter and risk men taking over the seats, as girls are doing st Stephen's?
Before deciding about that, one would need to know why men are not getting into the college. Its almost impossible to tell, but some possible causes are - boys go abroad to study rather more than girls do, still; is it that the brightest boys are therefore not applying at all? Secondly, males still prefer hard-core professional courses like engineering to even pure science or the arts - which form the bulk of courses at Stephen's. So, is the reduced presence of men an indication merely of their own choice?
Finally, reservations make sense only when the group needing reservations has been oppressed or discriminated against; and require support in order to reach their full potential. For men to claim that they are the discriminated -against gender requiring reservation - well, that's funny at one level and just pathetic at another. Its also illuminating - and irritating - that while for generations women have been under-represented at every possible forum without anyone bothering too much, as soon as male dominance ceases in one little area, there are people ready to make it into an issue.